Friday, August 24, 2007

Noonan "Toasts" US Troops

Here's an excerpt from a nice article by Peggy Noonan on the American soldiers of yesterday and today.
Some say we're the Roman Empire, but I don't think the soldiers of Rome were known for their kindness, nor the people of Rome for their decency. Some speak of Abu Ghraib, but the humiliation of prisoners there was news because it was American troops acting in a way that was out of the order of things, and apart from tradition. It was weird. And they were busted by other American troops.
You could say soldiers of every country do some good in war beyond fighting, and that is true enough. But this makes me think of the statue I saw once in Vienna, a heroic casting of a Red Army soldier. Quite stirring. The man who showed it to me pleasantly said it had a local nickname, "The Unknown Rapist." There are similar memorials in Estonia and Berlin; they all have the same nickname. My point is not to insult Russian soldiers, who had been born into a world of communism, atheism, and Stalin's institutionalization of brutish ways of being. I only mean to note the stellar reputation of American troops in the same war at the same time. They were good guys.

http://opinionjournal.com/columnists/pnoonan/?id=110010511

2 comments:

  1. i'm sure there are tons of things going on that nobody knows about. And it is stupid to say that abu ghraib was humiliating because it was weird and out ot the order of things. It was humiliating because of waht it was, that is that. go ask some iraqis if they have nicknames for us soldiers and I'll bet they have some good ones.

    ReplyDelete
  2. And your point is...?

    ReplyDelete